Skip to main content

Salmon With Caper-Anchovy Butter

Salmon with caperanchovy butter potatoes and a green salad on a plate.
Photo by Chelsea Kyle, Prop and Food Styling by Ali Nardi

"I'm addicted to the salmon with caper butter served at Marcello's Ristorante in Suffern, New York," says Anne Bergamo of Harriman, New York. "I'd love to be able to make the dish for a party — or just to add a little flair to a weeknight dinner."

Ingredients

Makes 6 Servings

4 garlic cloves
3 anchovy fillets
2 tablespoons drained capers
1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
1 tablespoon Cognac
1 tablespoon chopped fresh parsley
1/2 teaspoon ground black pepper
1/2 cup (1 stick) butter, room temperature
6 6-ounce salmon fillets
  1. Blend first 7 ingredients in food processor. Add butter and process until well blended. Season to taste with salt. Lay sheet of plastic wrap on work surface. Transfer butter mixture to plastic wrap and roll to form 9-inch-long log. Freeze until firm, about 1 hour. (Caper-anchovy butter can be prepared 1 week ahead. Keep frozen. Let butter soften slightly before using.) Position oven rack about 6 inches below broiler; preheat broiler. Place salmon fillets on broiler pan and sprinkle with salt and pepper. Broil salmon until just cooked through, about 8 minutes. Transfer to plates. Cut caper-anchovy butter into 1/2-inch-thick slices. Top each salmon fillet with 2 slices butter (reserve any remaining butter for another use). Serve salmon fillets hot.

Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Salmon With Caper-Anchovy Butter?

Leave a Review

Reviews (39)

Back to Top Triangle
  • Delish! Halved the recipe for a quick weeknight dinner for two. Took the recommendation to melt the butter before putting in the food processor, then threw it in the fridge while the salmon was broiling. Served it with boiled new potatoes and green beans with the butter topping it all. Yum!

    • sriver626

    • Chicago

    • 5/2/2018

  • I made this for my family. It was a very quick recipe once the compound butter is made. I made it using the ingredients. I think it was good. I cut this recipe in half, but kept the same amount of anchovies. I love the taste of anchovies! But I could see substituting the chives or thyme for the parsley. Either one would give it a different flavor punch to the butter. I could see using more of the other ingredients with less butter for more flavor. I liked it as it was with the extra anchovy punch.

    • pinklavender

    • Pittsburgh, Pa.

    • 3/19/2018

  • This was a great recipe. The butter was Great. I was skeptical about the anchovy overpowering the flavor but it was well balanced.

    • sidenator

    • Billings Montana

    • 5/11/2017

  • Love this! I Will definitely make it again.

    • 22redlips

    • Kirkland, Wa

    • 3/18/2017

  • i don't know, maybe i put in too many anchovies and garlic, but the butter overpowered the flavor of the fish. it went nicely on the simple potatoes i served on the side though. won't be making this again.

    • dlaviano

    • brooklyn, ny

    • 8/23/2016

  • I served this at a dinner party and every one raved about it. I made it exactly as written, and the butter was the most notable part the my guests loved. I did grill it outside in stead of broiling it, as it was in the summer and the temps were in the 90's and I didn't want to heat up the kitchen with the broiler. Served with a wild rice dish and a simple salad. Homemade ice cream and cookies for dessert. A wonderful summer meal.

    • flowerz

    • Lafayette, LA

    • 1/23/2016

  • Wow, it may be simple but the best flavor I've found in ages! We added a little fresh basil from the garden. My husband wants to keep in the fridge and use for many things!

    • WIGDOWT

    • Los Angeles, CA

    • 11/22/2015

  • It was nice, but nothing special.

    • foodlover1948

    • Brisbane, Australia

    • 11/21/2015

  • Simple and elegant. Full of great flavors. Be sure to either let the butter soften before serving, or just don't freeze it all to begin with.

    • sporklife

    • Boston, MA

    • 11/20/2015

  • this is just a compound butter.. one in a universe of them.. It was OK.. but then so are many.

    • sin1357

    • 11/19/2015

  • Wow. Agree with other reviewers - the Caper-Anchovy Butter is amazing. I have it in my fridge - it stores very well. I can't wait to use it again and plan on trying it for other purposes as others have recommended.

    • elenaaragona

    • DC

    • 6/18/2014

  • Recipe perfect as is. Have been abe to use the butter for other purposes also. Recipe's a keeper.

    • Anonymous

    • 8/9/2009

  • Amazing  just awesome, and super- easy. the easiest way: melt the butter to very soft or even liquid in the mircowave, then do the food processor (or even a blender) and freeze it while the salmon cooks (15-20 mins is plenty). then you can easily spread it on the fish. SO good.

    • ewaltrs

    • san francisco, ca

    • 8/21/2007

  • I thought this was great. After reading the reviews however, I doubled the amount of all ingredients, and used the amount of butter called for. I thought it was really good this way. It makes a lot of butter, which was great with the rosemary bread and asparagus I served alongside.

    • Anonymous

    • Tallahassee, FL

    • 2/2/2007

  • A slightly above average salmon dish as far as I am concerned. Took the suggestion to use half the butter and I dotted the butter mixture on the salmon prior to baking (I baked it at 375, not grilled it).

    • Anonymous

    • Winnetka, IL

    • 11/4/2006

See Related Recipes and Cooking Tips