Skip to main content

Barbecued Cowboy Steaks

Image may contain Steak Food and Meal
Barbecued Cowboy Steaks Mark Thomas

Those with Texas-size appetites will require an entire steak; for most others — even the heartiest of meat lovers — half of one of these rib steaks is probably plenty.

Ingredients

使4到8份

1 tablespoon coarse kosher salt
1 teaspoon Hungarian sweet paprika
1 teaspoon garlic powder
1 teaspoon coarsely ground black pepper
1 teaspoon dried ground thyme
1 teaspoon finely ground coffee beans
4 1 1/4- to 1 1/2-inch-thick bone-in beef rib steaks (each weighing 12 to 16 ounces)
1 2.2-pound bag instant-light mesquite chunks
1 cup mesquite or hickory wood smoke chips, soaked in cold water at least 30 minutes
  1. Step 1

    Mix first 6 ingredients in small bowl. Sprinkle spice rub over both sides of steaks, pressing to adhere. Let steaks stand at room temperature 1 hour.

    Step 2

    Spread entire bag of instant-light mesquite chunks over 2/3 of bottom rack and prepare barbecue (medium-high heat). Grill steaks over mesquite until brown on both sides, about 2 minutes per side. Remove steaks from grill. Let mesquite chunks burn until ash is gray. Drain wood chips; scatter over mesquite. Return steaks to cooler part of grill (not over mesquite). Cover barbecue with lid; grill steaks to desired doneness, about 10 minutes for medium-rare. Let steaks rest 5 minutes before serving.

Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Barbecued Cowboy Steaks?

Leave a Review

Reviews (95)

Back to Top Triangle
  • Nice. Easy and tasty. I added an eighth of cayenne pepper to the dry rub and briskly rubbed the steak after cooking with a piece of garlic to add more zest. Also, patting it lightly with canola oil is a good way to brown the outside, then finish it on an indirect grill to cook slowly and preserve the succulence.

    • danaskoglund

    • 8/21/2012

  • I used this rub all the time. On steaks, prime rib, etc. You can add some cayenne if you like it a little spicy - it is a great rub!

    • mamamoo67

    • Los Angeles, CA

    • 3/25/2012

  • This was really good. I used bone in New York steaks that I dry aged in the fridge for five days. Great flavor.

    • Timbob

    • Tehachapi, Cal

    • 1/31/2012

  • Best barbecued steaks ever. This will become our standard marinade from now on.

    • Anonymous

    • Shoal Harbour, NL

    • 9/26/2010

  • No fork rating because I didn't QUITE follow the recipe: I used 6 small strip steaks (3 1/2 lb.) and grilled over hickory charcoal, without the smoking step. There was just enough spice mixture to coat my 6 steaks on both sides. This rub was GOOD. Everyone was "mmm"ing throughout the meal. I couldn't really tell that there was any coffee involved, but the garlic-paprika-pepper-thyme action was great. I'll be making this again!

    • katastrophe

    • Washington, DC

    • 4/21/2010

  • This is the second time I have made this. First time did it on the grill as written and we were very pleased. This time, seared them in a VERY hot skillet to make a crust and they were to die! We honestly think this is one of the best steaks we have ever eaten. I threw a little kosher salt in the pan before searing and made the crust even more flavorful. Didnt need much else, just a big glass of Syrah and our appetites!

    • Anonymous

    • Crystal Coast of NC

    • 12/13/2009

  • Increddible flavor! I used the rub in this recipe and grilled boneless rib steaks on my gas grill. The flavors are intense, but not over powering. My husband loved it, and said it was probably the best steak he's eaten. I will definitely make this rub again and possibly use it on my holiday prime rib.

    • FriendlyFoodie

    • Woodinville, Wa

    • 11/22/2009

  • I used a rub without the coffee, but had the butcher cut 2 1/2 inch thick bone in rib eyes. I marinated the meat in a little red wine and garlic for a day in the fridge, then applied the rub and kept the meat cool until the Weber was really hot with hickory chunks added. A quick sear on the hot side before moving them to the cool side, tossing in a bunch of rosemary branches, created a great crust with a medium rare interior. Topped them a little butter, olive oil, and lemon. One steak per couple. Rave reviews from talented chefs. Take the meat off earlier than you think - at 125 degrees. With all that heat it continues to cook quite a bit while resting. Doing it again next month for our dinner club. Looking forward to the practice sessions.

    • lbeil

    • Richardson, TX

    • 7/20/2009

  • This spice rub is wonderful. The coffe adds a charred (but not burned) flavored that is fabulous. I found that there is no wiggle room on the thickness of the steaks...they must be thick or the spice rub ends up too salty for my taste.

    • panchita64

    • Albuquerque

    • 2/8/2009

  • This is the best steak that I have ever done. It is good infact, that my sister is flying me to upstate Vermont from San Francisco to cook for a party. I use a rib roast and divide it into several sections which makes it easier to cook for a crowd. Pricy, but well worth it.

    • amyesless

    • San Francisco

    • 8/17/2008

  • My experience cooking this for the second time last night was interesting, for it was not near as good as the first time (I goofed up managing the flame.) Last night it was just good: last week it was easily the best beef I had ever cooked, and probably ever eaten. So it just goes to show you the recipe by itself can only do so much. But, man, the first time it was UNBELIEVABLY good.

    • fortworth

    • Meadowbrook in Fort Worth

    • 7/5/2008

  • I always read the reviews but sometimes take them with a grain of salt -heh- particularly when people say "too rich" and "too salty." Most recipes have NEVER been "too" for me. But I have to agree with previous reviewers that the salt needs to be cut back a bit. If it is too salty for me, it is too salty for most I believe. First time I have ever said that! But otherwise a great and flavorful rub. Perfect for a meaty steak. Delish!

    • Anonymous

    • West Central Illinois

    • 6/26/2008

  • Spectacular! Easily the best steak I've ever grilled.

    • Anonymous

    • Richmond, VA

    • 6/8/2008

  • This recipe is the only way we cook steaks now. I probably have used it hundreds of times and each time, the steaks turn out delicious. Moist, tender, just fabulous. A tip: If there's some leftover rub, freeze it. It tastes just as good as "fresh". And decaf coffee tastes as good too. Try it -- you'll be hooked!

    • Anonymous

    • San Diego, CA

    • 5/24/2008

  • As all the others have stated, this is an instant classic. Living in Texas, I just tell out-of-state guests that this is just good ole Texas Steak.

    • Anonymous

    • Houston, TX

    • 5/10/2008

Read More
Yogurt-Marinated Chicken With Hot Honey and Herbs
Tenderizing yogurt makes the perfect marinade for grilled bone-in chicken thighs, which get even more flavor from chile-infused honey.
Steak Fajitas
Our best steak fajitas recipe features thin strips of skirt steak, marinated in citrus and grilled over mesquite, stuffed into warm flour tortillas.
Mojo Roast Pork and Gravy
Equal parts savory and bright, this Cuban holiday classic featuring versatile mojo sauce is a sure-fire crowd-pleaser.
Smothered Chicken With Cheesy Polenta
Crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside, this smothered fried chicken with polenta and herb gremolata is perfect for a dinner party.
Mustardy Grilled Cabbage and Kielbasa
This simple dinner of grilled sausage and cabbage gets added heft from small potatoes that go fork-tender in a foil packet in just under half an hour.
Sheet-Pan Merguez Hash With Fried Eggs
Free your merguez from its casings and have yourself a meal in no time. Runny yolks from crispy-edged fried eggs provide a saucy balance.
No-Skewer-Needed Kebabs With Onion Salad
Tender Turkish Adana-style kebabs are an essential addition to your summer grilling.
Cheesy Pork and Tomatillo Skillet
Teamed up with chips, this dip is the most popular snack in town. Or be like us and call it dinner.