Skip to main content

Basil Buttermilk Dressing

This tangy dressing really livens up a plate of crisp salad greens. It's also great on a baked potato or as a dip.

我ngredients

Makes about 1 cup, or 4 to 6 servings

1 small garlic clove
Rounded 1/4 teaspoon salt
2/3 cup well-shaken buttermilk
1/3 cup mayonnaise
2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh basil
  1. Step 1

    Mince garlic and mash to a paste with salt using a large heavy knife.

    Step 2

    Whisk together buttermilk, mayonnaise, basil, and garlic paste in a small bowl. Chill, covered, 1 hour to allow flavors to develop.

Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Basil Buttermilk Dressing?

Leave a Review

Reviews (16)

Back to Top Triangle
  • 我t's really enlightening to me to see how everyone tweaks this one. My salads are so busy with ingredients--I just put this for the first time on butter lettuce, avocado, walnuts, beets, tomato, cuke and mushrooms--that I actually found the modesty of the dressing best (other than balsamic and extra-virgin), creamy without being viscous.

    • Ralphwaldo

    • New York, NY

    • 5/14/2014

  • For me, this recipe is a good start but it's not there yet. Two tbsp of chopped basil wasn't quite enough, and I doubled that. I also added an equal amount of flat leaf parsley for some fresh 'green' flavour. I also added a tbsp of honey to add some depth. I'll definitely keep playing with this. Good find.

    • pauldub

    • New York, NY

    • 6/29/2012

  • Delish! Pressed sm garlic clove into BulletBlender container, added a sprinkle of salt, rest of ingredients, and maybe 1 T of crumbled stilton, lots of pepper. Gorgeous light green color and lovely, light but rich flavor. Can't wait to put it on our grilled romaine with a few toasted nuts.

    • Anonymous

    • Bend, OR

    • 7/30/2011

  • Taking a cue from another reviewer, I decided to spice things up by substituting cilantro and half of a seeded jalapeno pepper. The dressing was very good after it had been left to marinate in the fridge overnight. I am sure it would be delicious with fresh basil as well. The buttermilk base is very thick, and I found that I preferred it as a dip with crudites. If you want to use the dressing for salad greens, make sure you choose one with a hearty leaf such as romaine.

    • tastysausagerecipe

    • New York, NY

    • 6/22/2011

  • Delicious with arugula and tomato for a simple salad. I added a splash of apple cider vinegar and some fresh black pepper for a little bit extra something. Yum!

    • etwohig

    • boston, ma

    • 8/25/2010

  • Nice light flavor. Simple to make. Consistency is runny, though. I'd like it to cling to the salad a little more. Maybe next time I'll add a little cottage cheese to the mixture and blast it all in a blender.

    • Anonymous

    • Cary, NC

    • 7/24/2010

  • 我tweaked it a bit, adding fresh parsley and a pinch of cayenne.

    • south2nd

    • Austin

    • 4/5/2009

  • This was a good use of the buttermilk I had leftover from the red velvet cake, yet it seemed something was missing. I didn't find it tangy at all, and added 6 cloved of garlic to boot. The salt rang through clear as a bell even though I used precisely 1/4 teaspoon... Overall, the flavors were salt, cream and basil. It leaves me wondering what the missing taste that I expected could possibly have been...

    • Devilduckie

    • Live Oak

    • 12/16/2008

  • So easy and well received. Great with avocado too!

    • Anonymous

    • Toronto

    • 11/23/2008

  • So easy and tastes great

    • scf211

    • Annandale, VA

    • 9/15/2008

  • 我做了这个使用了一些新鲜罗勒酱。我t was good, but I made a similar one a few days ago with simply mayo, a splash of milk, basil, and salt, which was much tastier.

    • MaryCook1

    • New York, NY

    • 6/4/2006

  • This recipe or one VERY similar was in Bon Appetit a few years ago as a dressing for sliced tomatos. It's great on sliced tomatos with some finely sliced basil sprinkled over for garnish.

    • oheck8

    • Des Moines, Iowa

    • 5/7/2006

  • 我poured this over iceberg wedges and served it with barbecued ribs on a very hot summer night. The delicious salad was the most refreshing part of the meal. (The next morning, my 11-year-old daughter's friend asked me for the recipe "so my mom can make it too".) I'm going to make a large quantity of this and just keep it on hand in the fridge. Can't wait to try it with other salad greens.

    • DWuerfel

    • 8/9/2005

  • Pure summer flavor, great on lettuces or green beans or just your index finger. I shall try this on pasta salad with tomatoes and green beans and corn and shall probably love it!

    • lisamargaret

    • Santa Barbara, CA

    • 6/13/2005

  • great and easy! i just tossed it with baby spinach and it made a very tasty weeknight salad. much better than store bought.

    • Anonymous

    • chicago

    • 3/21/2005

Read More
Korean Potato Salad
Often served in a tidy scoop, this creamy, tangy, subtly sweet potato salad goes great with whatever’s coming off the grill.
Spring Potato Salad With Rhubarb
我n addition to potatoes, this creamy springtime side dish is made with lightly simmered rhubarb.
German Potato Salad With Dill
This oil-and-vinegar-dressed German potato salad is the light, bright side dish your BBQ needs.
Green Mango, Cabbage, and Jicama Salad
Cutting out the protein not only makes this green mango salad less fussy (read: faster to make) but also highlights the tropical flavor combinations.
Green Tomato–Berry Salad With Sumac Dressing
Rethink green tomatoes—in this savory-sweet, make-ahead salad, they’re fresh and juicy. It’s a knockout addition to any cookout.
Buttermilk Pie
The filling for this easy buttermilk pie comes together in just under 10 minutes.
Herby Buttermilk Vinaigrette
This herby buttermilk vinaigrette was first made for Aretha Franklin when she used to come into Le Bernardin.
BA’s Best Buttermilk Biscuits
Stacking and flattening the dough creates lots and lots of flaky layers that beg to be pulled apart and slathered with softened butter.