Skip to main content

Grilled Cheddar and Fennel Sandwiches with Curry Mayo

Image may contain Food Bread Dish Meal Burger Pottery French Toast and Toast
Photo by Romulo Yanes
  • Active Time

    25 min

  • Total Time

    25 min

Ingredients

Makes 4 servings

2 tablespoons finely chopped shallot
2 teaspoons curry powder (preferably Madras)
1 teaspoon vegetable oil
1/2 cup mayonnaise
1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
1 baguette
1 1/2 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
1/2 lb extra-sharp Cheddar
1/4 cup very thinly sliced fennel bulb (sometimes called anise; quartered lengthwise and cored before slicing)
  1. Step 1

    Cook shallot and curry powder in oil in a 12-inch heavy nonstick skillet over moderate heat, stirring, 2 minutes, then transfer to a small bowl and stir in mayonnaise and lemon juice. Wipe skillet clean and set aside.

    Step 2

    Cut 16 (1/4-inch-thick) diagonal slices (about 6 inches long) from baguette. Spread 1 side of each slice with butter, then turn over and spread opposite side with curry mayonnaise. Cut cheese into thin slices no wider than bread slices. Divide cheese among 8 slices of bread, then top with fennel and remaining slices of bread, buttered sides up.

    Step 3

    Heat skillet over moderate heat until hot, then cook sandwiches in 2 batches, turning over once and pressing occasionally, until browned and cheese is melted, about 7 minutes per batch.

Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Grilled Cheddar and Fennel Sandwiches with Curry Mayo?

Leave a Review

Reviews (17)

Back to Top Triangle
  • Excellent sandwich w/slight change. Made with homemade bread in a panini press.

    • dherron

    • 7/24/2012

  • Curry mayo makes it fantastic. I used gruyere. I didn't have fennel--so I made two batches with alternatives. Sauteed leeks or raw green apples. Both great--and apples paired really nicely with curry.

    • efgelber

    • Brooklyn, NY

    • 2/26/2012

  • 我刻花茴香,结局也许thicker slices than most. I liked the crunch and thought the taste balance was refreshing. Easy, impressive lunch for guests.

    • SheRat

    • San Francisco, CA

    • 1/25/2011

  • WOW - this was unbelievably delicious....i made exactly as stated, except (of course) i used garlic instead of shallots (to avoid trip to the store) and olive oil (i don't even have veggie oil in my house). also, i roasted the fennel. sooooo good. who comes up with this stuff? thank god for them!

    • Anonymous

    • los angeles

    • 3/21/2010

  • After reviewing the comments below, I used granny smith apple instead of fennel AND pumpernickel. Flavorful and unique. Reminds me of what you would find on a menu at a hip, vegetarian restaurant.

    • dunnkit

    • Seattle

    • 1/6/2010

  • Loved it! I do agree that the fennel was not as pronounced as I thought it would. I'll try sauteing and/or thicker slices. Also as another poster recommends, the pumpernickel sounds like a wonderful variant.

    • abar65

    • Annapolis, MD

    • 10/10/2008

  • If you roast your fennel, try adding thinly sliced apples for crunch. Apples & fennel go very well together.

    • Anonymous

    • CA

    • 9/2/2008

  • Delectable!! But don't tell your cardiologist! I roasted the fennel as suggested by a previous reviewer but otherwise followed the recipe exactly.

    • janewerf

    • SF Bay Are

    • 2/18/2008

  • I didn't think that this sandwich was exceptional.

    • Anonymous

    • Venice, CA

    • 12/19/2007

  • Instead of fresh fennel, I roasted the fennel, thinly sliced with some olive oil and garlic cloves until lightly browned. It took the sandwiches to the next level.

    • Anonymous

    • Toronto

    • 8/19/2007

  • Very good. The curry mayo is great on other kind of sandwiches too. The fennel seemed odd, but works perfectly.

    • vk1

    • Reston, VA

    • 12/10/2006

  • I made these to accompany the Spicy Tomato Soup. I loved the curry mayo. My word of advice is to apply the butter, mayo and cheese in very modest proportions, because when you add them all up, you've got a very rich (fatty) little sandwich. Delish, though!

    • christina

    • Seattle

    • 12/7/2006

  • We have made this recipe over 10 times. It is our favorite grilled cheese - the curry mayo rocks! We love the fennel as is. I've sliced by hand, so maybe thicker slices make the fennel more pronounced. This is also great with pumpernickel or sourdough. If you are using the baguette, keep the slices thin or chewing the sandwich becomes a little challenging.

    • Anonymous

    • Minneapolis

    • 3/1/2006

  • Unexpected combination and fabulous taste. I agree with the other posters about roasting the fennel first, to help bring out the anise flavour more and soften the fennel (although the crispness wasn't bad). The curry is an excellent accompaniment.

    • Cymry

    • Northeast PA

    • 12/5/2005

  • Yummy! Definately will make again. I used my mandolin (sp?) to slice the fennel extra thin. I love love love fennel, but do agree with the other poster that you really couldn't taste it. Maybe next time I will roast the fennel first and then add it to the sandwich.

    • Anonymous

    • Los Angeles

    • 6/6/2005

Read More
Beet and Mushroom Miso Ragù
No funky, hard-to-pronounce ingredients in this versatile meat substitute, just lots of beets and chickpeas for texture and miso for a bit of umami.
Hummus Bowls With Merguez-Spiced Tempeh
This vegan twist on a lamb sausage hummus bowl features a trio of textures—creamy, crisp, and meaty—that will keep you coming back for more.
Crispy Salmon With Fennel-Date Salad
Crispy salmon skin, crunchy fennel salad, and creamy tahini yogurt make this a texture-seeker’s dream dinner.
Crunchy Cabbage Salad With Caraway Seeds
This fresh cabbage salad is always welcome addition to a spread with glazed ham, to add texture to fried fish sandwiches, or as a side dish at summer barbecues.
Classic Mayonnaise
If you’ve ever looked at a jar of mayo and wondered, “So what is this stuff exactly?” this homemade mayonnaise recipe is for you.
Chicken Cutlets With Burst-Tomato Sauce
Warm and fragrant, this sauce is a versatile use for a surplus of cherry tomatoes. Spoon any leftovers over pork chops, grain bowls, or cheese and crackers.
Sunny Saffron Butter Pasta
A little saffron goes a long way in this standout sauce, finished with cracked pepper, salty Parmesan, and fragrant basil.
Gingery Chicken Noodle Soup
Curry powder, lime juice, and skin-on, bone-in chicken thighs amp up boxed stock, delivering massive flavor in minimal time—all in one pot.