Skip to main content

Torquato's Herb and Garlic Baked Tomatoes

I love many versions of baked stuffed tomatoes, but the simple recipe of Torquato Innocenti, who sells tomatoes in Florence's Piazza Santo Spirito market, is my favorite. Nothing more than garlic, basil or parsley, and "good oil" fills the tomatoes.

Ingredients

Serves 4 to 6

15 vine-ripened plum tomatoes
1/2 cup packed fresh basil or flat-leafed parsley leaves, washed well and spun dry
4 garlic cloves
1/4 cup extra-virgin olive oil
fine sea salt to taste
freshly ground black pepper to taste
  1. Step 1

    Preheat oven to 400° F.

    Step 2

    Halve tomatoes lengthwise and scoop out seeds with a small spoon. Arrange tomatoes in one layer, cut sides up, on a non-stick or lightly oiled jelly-roll pan.

    Step 3

    In a small food processor blend basil, garlic, oil, salt, and pepper until mixture forms a paste and spread about 1/2 teaspoon in each tomato half.

    Step 4

    Bake tomatoes 30 to 40 minutes, or until tender and juicy but intact, and cool slightly before serving.

Reprinted with permission fromRed, White, and Greens: The Italian Way With Vegetables, copyright 1996 by Faith Willinger. Buy the full book onAmazon.
Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Torquato's Herb and Garlic Baked Tomatoes?

Leave a Review

Reviews (11)

Back to Top Triangle
  • Great alongside Italian chicken sausage and risotto. I added bread crumbs and goat cheese to the tomatoes before putting them in the oven. Bake time was under 20 minutes.

    • fiveoclocksomewhere

    • seattle, wa

    • 4/7/2013

  • Very nice, easy dish. I added bread crumbs and goat cheese to the tomatoes before putting them in the oven. Delicious alongside Italian chicken sausage and risotto.

    • fiveoclocksomewhere

    • Seattle, WA

    • 4/7/2013

  • Really liked the taste - I also added bread crumbs and romano cheese. I found the baking time in the recipe to be far too long - 20 minutes would have been perfect.

    • johnmriske

    • Minneapolis

    • 2/18/2007

  • Excellent recipe! I followed the other recommendations and added bread crumbs and parmesian cheese. I didn't have fresh basil, so I added dried basil mixed with fresh parsley. Delicious.

    • Anonymous

    • Madison, NJ

    • 2/9/2006

  • 我添加了面包屑大蒜/草药混合物。Drizzled olive oil over and baked. Served it with the Stuffed Zucchini recipe (Little Italy) on this site and it was great. It's a good way to use up lots of garden tomatoes.

    • Anonymous

    • Fairfield, CT

    • 9/22/2005

  • A wonderful accompaniment to grilled salmon fillets with creamy horseradish sauce (also on epicurious). Great flavor - make sure you use a quality extra virgin olive oil! I topped the tomatoes with crumbles of feta cheese. A real popular dish with my husband and our friends!

    • Brenda4

    • Long Beach, CA

    • 5/1/2005

  • Excellent light dish. I agree with previous cooks about adding pinenuts to the mixture and goat cheese to the top at the end. I also added a few breadcrumbs from pita bread to the mixture give it some extra thinkness. Great, easy recipe.

    • Lauren

    • Manhattan Beach, CA

    • 5/13/2004

  • Simple and totally delicious. I used the last of the summer tomatoes and parsley. I also added a few pinenuts to the mixture based on one of the previous comments.

    • Anonymous

    • Oakland, CA

    • 11/9/2002

  • I used tomatoes from the garden and added a table spoon or so of Feta Cheese to the basil mix. It was really wonderful.

    • Anonymous

    • Tallahassee, FL

    • 6/11/2000

  • These were a great side dish to a very rich main course that was heavy in dairy. they added an acidic quality to the meal that was a great balance to the creamy/cheesy polenta that they accompanied.

    • Anonymous

    • San Francisco

    • 4/4/2000

  • Wonderful!! I also added some parmesean cheese and some pine nuts to the processor. Very easy and great taste. Wonderful with lamb.

    • Anonymous

    • Pagosa Springs, CO

    • 3/26/1999

Read More
Garlic Bread
This easy garlic bread recipe turns out a rich, buttery loaf topped with crispy Parmesan. Make it to accompany any soup, salad, or pasta.
Curried Tomato Sandwich
Sandwich your summer tomato bounty between mayo-slathered slices of fried bread sizzled in curry powder.
Ginger-Garlic Half Chicken
Combine ginger, garlic, fermented chili-bean paste, and soy sauce to make a flavorful marinade for grilled half chickens.
Shrimp and Tomato Toasts
This toast is loaded with bright aioli, punchy tomatoes, and smoky shrimp—it definitely requires a fork and knife.
Blistered Cherry Tomato Toast
Turn summer’s bounty into a full meal with some blistered cherry tomatoes, cooling yogurt, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze piled on top of fried bread.
Tangy Tomato-Chile Popcorn
Tomato powder makes a simple umami-packed seasoning you’ll want to lick off your fingers while you’re snacking.
Tomato Salad With Basil Vinaigrette
Salting and straining ripe tomatoes extracts their flavorful juices; when combined with verdant basil oil, it makes a slightly sweet and vegetal salad dressing.
Sun-Dried-Tomato Romesco Pasta
When you’re short on time, skip the canned tomatoes and reach for ultra-concentrated sun-dried ones, which can be blitzed straight into sauce.