Skip to main content

Creamy Any-Pickle Dressing

Buttermilk dill fronds pickled vegetables and lemon juice in a bowl with a spoon.
Photo by Joseph De Leo, Food Styling by Rebecca Jurkevich
  • Active Time

    5 minutes

  • Total Time

    1 hour 5 minutes

What would happen if pickle dip metranch? This dressing. Creamy, tangy, and briny to the max, the base starts with buttermilk, sour cream, dehydrated onion flakes,garlic powder, and the star of the show: pickles. While this dressing can be made with just one type of pickle (like classic dill varieties), it’s even tastier when made with a mix of pickled vegetables like cocktail onions,capers, pickled green beans,cornichons, and hot cherry peppers. It’s a great opportunity to play with different flavor profiles—like sweet, tangy, briny, or spicy—and tailor the dressing to your tastes depending on the variety you use. If a little sweetness is what you’re after, you can add some bread-and-butter pickles into the mix. Or, for a little bit of heat, try adding pickled jalapeños. It’s a fantastic way to use up any jar of pickled things you might have in the back of the fridge.

Because pickles come in so many shapes and sizes, a good rule of thumb is to measure them out by weight, not volume. But if you don’t have akitchen scale, start with the lower end of the cup measurement and add more pickles to taste as you build the dressing. Use this dressing to makeTomato PanzanellaorGrilled Chicken Salad(where it also doubles as a marinade), or spoon it over roasted potatoes, wedges of iceberg lettuce, or grilled vegetables, such as green beans or asparagus.

Note: For smaller, stronger pickled items such as capers, use only about ½–1 oz. (1–2 Tbsp.) total and combine them with larger, more mild pickles so the flavor of the dressing is not too strong.

All products featured on Epicurious are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

What you’ll need

Ingredients

Makes about 2¼ cups

5 oz. pickled vegetables (such as dill pickles, cornichons, cocktail onions, peperoncini, capers, jalapeños, and/or hot cherry peppers, cut into 1" pieces if large; ⅔–1 cup), plus 4½ tsp. pickle brine
¼ cup (loosely packed) dill fronds
½ cup buttermilk
4½ tsp. dehydrated onion flakes
1 Tbsp. fresh lemon juice
1½ tsp. Diamond Crystal or 1 tsp. Morton kosher salt, plus more
1½ tsp. garlic powder
½ tsp. freshly ground pepper
½ tsp. sugar
1 cup sour cream
  1. Step 1

    Pulse5 oz. pickled vegetables (such as dill pickles, cornichons, cocktail onions, peperoncini, capers, jalapeños, and/or hot cherry peppers), drained, cut into 1" pieces if large; ⅔–1 cup), and¼ cup (loosely packed) dill frondsin a food processor, scraping down sides as needed, until finely chopped (15–20 pulses). Add½ cup buttermilk,4½ tsp. pickle brine,4½ tsp. dehydrated onion flakes,1 Tbsp. fresh lemon juice,1½ tsp. Diamond Crystal or 1 tsp. Morton kosher salt,1½ tsp. garlic powder,½ tsp. freshly ground pepper, and½ tsp. sugarand pulse to combine (5–10 pulses).

    Step 2

    Transfer mixture to an airtight container and stir in1 cup sour cream. Taste dressing and season with more salt if needed. Cover and chill at least 1 hour. (Don’t skip the resting period; it allows the onion flakes to rehydrate and all of the flavors to meld.)

    Do Ahead:Dressing can be made 5 days ahead. Keep chilled.

Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Creamy Any-Pickle Dressing?

Leave a Review

  • My kids loved it. Husband enjoyed it. I made this with the fresh pickles from Sr. Baghari and one of my home fermented jalapeno en escabeche, no fresh dill (had already used it up making the pickles) and fresh garlic not dried, pickled onion not dried. Jalapeno brine not pickle brine. Was delicious, and I do think this framework would work for many different types of pickled vegetables.

    • RobinFL

    • South of the south

    • 8/3/2023

See Related Recipes and Cooking Tips

Read More
Grilled Chicken Salad With Creamy Any-Pickle Dressing
The classic combination of grilled chicken and bottled ranch gets a summer glow-up in this barbecue-ready salad.
Fried Chicken With Cranberry-Mustard Sauce
Free up your oven and make the case for crispy, crunchy, sage and thyme-y fried chicken this Thanksgiving.
Tangy Grilled Chicken Wings With Quick Giardiniera
Think Buffalo wings—saucy chicken, cheesy dip, crunchy vegetables—but turned slightly on its head with whipped feta and handheld giardiniera.
Easy-to-Love Chicken Thighs and Couscous
Everyone needs a back-pocket chicken marinade, and this pantry-friendly version lives up to its name. Great both on the grill and under the broiler.
Halal Cart Chicken Salad
This flavorful dinner salad—inspired by the street food favorite—is made super speedy with the addition of store-bought rotisserie chicken.
Simple Spinach Khichdi
This creamy, comforting khichdi is ready for any lentil in your pantry. Frozen spinach and fresh herbs keep it bright and perky.
Crystal’s Peppery Chicken and Dumplings
This one-pot dish is fallback comfort food—thick black-pepper-spiked chicken stew topped with tender, fluffy dumplings.
Sheet-Pan Merguez Hash With Fried Eggs
Free your merguez from its casings and have yourself a meal in no time. Runny yolks from crispy-edged fried eggs provide a saucy balance.