Skip to main content

Meyer Lemon Cream Pies

Image may contain Food Egg Creme Dessert Cream Plant Nut and Vegetable
Photo by Yunhee Kim
  • Prep Time

    15 minutes Total time

  • Total Time

    1 hour, 15 minutes

A Meyer lemon is a cross between a lemon and a mandarin orange. If you can't find any, substitute regular lemons. This pie's decadent cream filling is made from protein-rich tofu.

Ingredients

Makes 4 servings

For the crust:

1 1/4 cups graham-cracker crumbs
2 tablespoons sugar
5 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted

For the filling:

2 (12-ounce) containers firm silken tofu (such as Mori-Nu)
Grated zest and juice of 2 Meyer lemons
1/2 cup confectioners' sugar
  1. Step 1

    1. Preheat oven to 350°F.

    Step 2

    2. In a medium bowl, mix together all the crust ingredients. Press the mixture into the bottom and sides of four tartlet molds or 4-ounce ramekins.

    Step 3

    3. Bake until golden brown, 8 to 10 minutes. Remove and let cool completely.

    Step 4

    4. In a blender, combine all the filling ingredients until smooth, spoon the mixture into the crusts, and refrigerate for at least 1 hour.

Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Meyer Lemon Cream Pies?

Leave a Review

  • i left a negative review below that i meant to delete. i found the taste is greatly improved by sitting overnight in the refrigerator. it was night and day in terms of taste. i agree with one reviewer who wondered why 24 oz of tofu is needed to fill 4 small tartlet pans. i will make with a single container and taste and look at volumn before adding second container

    • scotttulsa

    • tulsa, oklahoma

    • 2/14/2017

  • What a scrumptious, light and refreshing dessert! I appreciate a tofu alternative to one of my favorite pies. I can understand how some palates would find this recipe not to their liking especially if one is used to super sweet treats. Try pairing this with a lighter Spring meal and more water as your beverage. You might be pleasantly satisfied. The sweet crunch of the graham cracker crust perfectly complimented the barely tart/just sweet enough pie filling. Nice...

    • miss_erynne

    • New Orleans, LA

    • 4/11/2016

  • I was highly disappointed in this recipe. It looked so good--and so easy--but the filling had no flavor! I ended up adding the juice of 1 more Meyer lemon and another 1/2 cup of confectioner's sugar, but that only made it passable. And it still didn't cover up the flavor of the silken tofu.

    • vwm1942

    • Midlothian, VA

    • 1/30/2011

  • Yummy. My husband made this for me. Unable to find Meyer Lemons, he substituted key lime juice. We actually ate it the following day. The texture was very creamy , no chalky taste as another reviewer had noted. Mori-Nu silken was what was used. The filling itself would be a great sustitute for whipped cream on top of warm gingerbread or between ginger snaps then frozen for mini "icecream" sandwiches!

    • Zuzi

    • Marriottsville, MD

    • 8/20/2010

  • I liked this recipe. I have made similar with chocolate, and thought the lemon would be a nice summer sub. The tofu tasted chalky, and I used more lemon than recommended. LOTS MORE ZEST, for flavor. I also made one with limes, and added a bit of vanilla. Also, I added a dropper of vanilla, and topped them both with blueberries. They were OK. Probably would stick with the chocolate.

    • bandonchef

    • 8/9/2010

  • horrible recipe. it doesn't taste good. i used the silken firm tofu as recommended. i admit i've not let it cool for an hour. perhaps it gets better. a bigger problem is the amount of filling that is created for four small tartlett pans. mine hold about a half a cup of liquid when empty. when filled with crust, they hold much less. this recipe makes a blender full of filling when at most you need 1 1/4 cups. perhaps only one container of tofu was intended??? i grew those meyer lemons and i resent their sacrifice.

    • scotttulsa

    • tulsa, ok

    • 2/9/2010

  • The tofu flavor should not be evident if you use "silken" tofu - especially Mori-Nu brand. Perhaps the reviewer used regular tofu.

    • LauraStokesGray

    • Wheaton

    • 1/9/2008

  • Made this tonight-- it was awful. Added extra sugar and lemon juice, but the tofu flavor was overpowering.

    • Anonymous

    • Chicago, IL

    • 12/5/2007

See Related Recipes and Cooking Tips

Read More
Sheet-Pan Orange Tofu and Broccoli
A take-out favorite meets sheet-pan dinner in this vegetarian take on orange chicken, featuring extra-firm tofu and a fresh, zingy sauce.
Stir-Fried String Beans With Tofu
Other types of plant-based protein, such as tempeh or seitan, can be used in this green bean stir-fry.
Tofu and Green Pea Curry
A heavily spiced sauce and pops of green peas makes bland tofu a distant memory. Easy to veganize (just skip the butter), this curry is an excellent make-ahead meal.
Jam Muffins
A baked take on the doughnut-shop classic, these jelly-filled muffins make everyone giddy.
Food Truck Chocolate Chip Cookies
Try pastry chef Claudia Fleming's all-time favorite chocolate chip cookies.
Creamy-Dreamy Strawberry-Banana Smoothie
Everything you want in an easy strawberry smoothie, it’s perfectly creamy from milk, Greek yogurt, and bananas, and just sweet enough from a dollop of honey.
Honey Oat Cookies
Rolled oats and flaked coconut come together to make a soft, chewy cookie with lots of flavor.
Triple Charlotte Russe
This multilayered, rich, and colorful cake takes some effort to make, but the sponge cake and ladyfingers can be made a day in advance.