Skip to main content

Old-Fashioned Shortening Pie Dough

Photo of pie dough recipe.
Photo by Emulsion Studio

This is a pretty standard all-shortening piecrust, like the one my dad used when I was a youngster. A shortening piecrust won’t have the delicate flavor of a butter crust, and the texture is typically more crumbly, less flaky. Still, this yields a delicious, tender crust that many bakers believe makes the best pies.

The softness of the shortening makes this an easy recipe to double. For a double-crust-pie, simply double all of the ingredients and proceed as below. Divide the dough in two when it comes out of the bowl, making one part slightly larger than the other if you’re using it for a top and bottom crust.

Ingredients

One 9- to 9½-inch standard or deep-dish pie shell

1½ cups all-purpose flour
1 tablespoon confectioners’ sugar (optional for a sweet pie; omit for a savory pie)
½ teaspoon salt
½ cup cold vegetable shortening
¼–⅓ cup cold water
  1. Step 1

    Combine the flour, sugar (if using), and salt in a large bowl; refrigerate for 15 minutes.

    Step 2

    缩短添加到干燥的配料和搅拌it with your hands to coat, then break it up into smaller pieces. Using a pastry blender, cut the shortening into the dry ingredients until the pieces of fat are roughly the size of small peas and everything looks like it has been touched by the fat. There should be no dry, floury areas.

    Step 3

    Mound the ingredients in the center of the bowl. Drizzle about half of the water down the sides of the bowl, turning the bowl as you pour so the water doesn’t end up in one spot. Using a large fork, lightly mix the dough, tossing it from the perimeter toward the center of the bowl. Drizzle most of the remaining water here and there over the dough and toss again.

    Step 4

    Mix the dough vigorously now. The dough should start to gather in large clumps, but if it is dry in places, stir in the rest of the water.

    Step 5

    Turn the dough out onto a lightly floured work surface and pack it into a ball, then knead it several times to smooth it out. Put the dough on a sheet of plastic wrap and flatten it into a ¾-inch-thick disk. Wrap the disk and refrigerate for about 1 hour before rolling.

FromPie Academy© 2020 by Ken Haedrich. Reprinted with permission from Storey Publishing. Buy the full book fromAmazonorBookshop.
Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Old-Fashioned Shortening Pie Dough?

Leave a Review

  • when we remodled for a granite counter top, I saved the plugs that was cut out for the sink. I keep those in the freezer and when i make pies i use the ice cold plugs to work my pie crusts on and my pie crusts come out awesome. I also put equal amounts of frangelica ( hazel nut liquer ) or orange liquer in with the cider vinegar and reduce the amt of water .

    • Royal B

    • northern calif.

    • 10/31/2021

See Related Recipes and Cooking Tips

Read More
Easy Hot Cross Muffins
These fruit-laden muffins smell exactly like hot cross buns as they bake and taste just as satisfying, but with a fraction of the effort.
Lemon Cornmeal Scones
Think Italian-style lemon cornmeal cake, served in scone form. These lemon cornmeal scones are great to have in your freezer at all times.
Charred Green Beans With Brown Butter Vinaigrette
This green bean stir-fry is a punchy holiday side dish, featuring a crunchy hazelnut-sage topping and a lush brown butter vinaigrette.
Cilantro Roast Cod and Cabbage With Herb Salad
This flavorful and quick cod and cabbage sheet-pan meal owes its flavor to a punchy green marinade featuring fish sauce and black pepper.
Grapefruit Crudo
Treating grapefruit like raw fish gives you permission to get as fancy as you’d like plating and arranging this textural winter salad.
Maple Pecan Scones
Pecans take on a lovely maple taste with caramel tones when toasted, so they're amazing in this nutty maple scone recipe.
Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie
Our favorite recipe for strawberry-rhubarb pie gets a crumb topping with cinnamon and brown sugar and a flaky, buttery bottom crust for the best of both worlds.
BA’s Best Pumpkin Pie
The sweetened condensed milk adds a decadent richness to the custard, while the perfect ratio of spices highlights the flavors of the pumpkin.