Skip to main content

Chief of Staff Cholent (Hebronite Hamim)

Editor's note:The recipe and introductory text below are excerpted from Joan Nathan's bookThe Foods of Israel Today.Nathan also shared some helpful cooking tips exclusively with Epicurious, which we've added at the bottom of the page.

To read more about Nathan and Israeli cuisine,click here.

According to the Ten Commandments, "On the seventh day thou shalt rest," which means that no cooking can be done on the Sabbath. This tradition is the reason Israel is truly the center of the world forcholent,an overnight stew. Almost all Jewish families have brought their own unique versions — with Hungarian smoked goose breast, Brazilian black beans, Moroccan rice, Bukharan turkey giblets and raisin-stuffed cucumbers, or Polish barley and meat. A dish that has experienced a rebirth even among secular Israelis in the last few years,cholentis often served as a centerpiece main course for parties, usually blending several traditions in one exciting creation.

Eons ago, needing a dish that could be kept warm for the Sabbath, Jewish cooks came up with an overnight stew, the ingredients for which varied depending on where they lived. The stew was tightly sealed, often with a paste-like dough, and cooked before the Sabbath began, then left overnight in the embers to warm until the next day. During World War II, before Israelis had proper ovens, thecholentoften was simmered over the small flame of a kerosene stove, the lid covered with two heavy bricks.

The word cholent comes from the Frenchchaud,meaning "warm," andlent,meaning "slow." In Israel, it is also calledhamim,Hebrew for "warm." Like outdoor grilling, preparingcholentseems to have become the Israeli man's domain. It is served on every Israeli army base on Saturday, even in small military units on their own at lookout posts throughout the country, since the army, which officially observes the dietary laws, must serve a traditional Sabbath meal.

This Hebronitehamimrecipe was given to me by Amnon Lipkin Shachak, a former Israeli army chief of staff. He combines the Ashkenazic basic beans and barley with Sephardic sausages and the long-cooking eggs in their shells calledhuevos haminadavto make an innovative Sabbath dish from Hebron, the city from which part of his family hails. According to him, the recipe changes each time he makes it, depending on what he can find in the cupboard. This version requireskishke(a traditional delicacy made of flour and fat stuffed into sausage casing, today obtainable from Jewish specialty stores) and the robust and highly aromatic eastern Mediterranean spice combination ofbaharat(see Tips, below).

Ingredients

Yield: 10 to 12 servings

1 1/2 cups white or red kidney beans
1 1/2 cups chickpeas
2 large onions, chopped
2 tablespoons vegetable oil
1/2 cup light-brown sugar
1/4 cup water
4-pound beef brisket, with fat
1 cup long-grain rice
1 teaspoon salt
Freshly ground pepper to taste
1 cup parched wheat(frika),bulgur, or barley
4-5 beef soup bones
1 poundkishke
1 pound pearl onions
5 medium potatoes, peeled and halved
6 large eggs in the shell
2 tablespoonsbaharat,or to taste
4-5 teaspoons beef soup powder or 4 beef bouillon cubes
  1. Step 1

    1. On Thursday night, soak the white or red beans and chickpeas in cold water to cover.

    Step 2

    2. On Friday morning, in a large heavy pot, sauté the onions in the vegetable oil until translucent. Then add the brown sugar and the water and carefully caramelize the onions over very low heat. Turn off the heat until the remaining ingredients are prepared.

    Step 3

    3. Drain the beans and scatter them on top of the onions.

    Step 4

    4. Cut the fat from the brisket, dice the fat, and set it aside. Rinse the rice in cold water and then drain; repeat twice more. Season the rice with 1/2 teaspoon salt and a few grinds of black pepper and dot with about 4 tablespoons of cubed beef fat. Place the rice in the center of a sheet of cheesecloth and enclose it loosely, so that the rice can expand. Tie with a thin strip of cheesecloth or twine and set aside.

    Step 5

    5. Season thefrika,bulgur, or barley with 1/2 teaspoon salt and a few grinds of black pepper, dot with about 4 tablespoons of cubed beef fat, and put it in another piece of cheesecloth. Tie it up loosely.

    Step 6

    6. Add the beef bones to the onions in the pot. Set the brisket on top, then the 2 bags of grains, thekishke,pearl onions, potatoes, and eggs. Sprinkle with additional salt to taste, pepper,baharat,and soup powder. Add water to cover, cover the pot, and ring to a boil. Then transfer to a preheated 200-degree oven to cook overnight or put the pot on ablech(a heated asbestos pad which many Jewish cooks use to keep Sabbath dishes warm) over low heat and leave until ready to serve.

  2. Joan Nathan shares her tips with Epicurious:

    Step 7

    •For this dish, Nathan prefers the texture and flavor of dried chickpeas and beans to canned.
    •Baharat, an Eastern Mediterranean spice blend, generally includes paprika, hot pepper, black pepper, cumin, coriander, cinnamon, allspice, nutmeg, cardamom, cloves, and salt. It is available at Middle Eastern markets. If you can't find it, Nathan recommends using your favorites from the list above, being sure to include pepper.
    •"This dish can easily be made in a slow cooker," says Nathan. "Sauté the onions and place them in the cooker, then add the drained beans and other ingredients. Leave the dish to cook throughout the day or overnight."

Reprinted with permission fromThe Foods of Israel Todayby Joan Nathan, copyright © 2001. Published by Knopf.
Sign InorSubscribe
to leave a Rating or Review

How would you rate Chief of Staff Cholent (Hebronite Hamim)?

Leave a Review

  • 这将是一个不错的炖牛肉没有addition of all that sugar, which I am sorely regretting. It's not needed to caramelize onions, and nothing fails to go with sugar like beef.

    • Anonymous

    • Albuquerque

    • 9/23/2009

  • I also like to put whole cloves of garlic in cholent...turns out nice and tasty when roasted with the rest.

    • Anonymous

    • NYC

    • 4/4/2008

  • For the people who are concerned about how to serve: there are 2 schools of thought. One is to omit the cheesecloth and cook everything together which is the eastern european way of doing it. Then fish out the eggs, let cool and shell and serve them sliced on the side as garnish. The middle easter way is to fish out the cheesecloth bags and serve the barley and rice on the side in seperate dishes and the kishka too if you are using it and the egg too and then serve the (cholent) stew in a big dish.

    • juliesd

    • La Jolla, CA

    • 11/29/2005

  • Excellent. The only change I made was to use about 6 large onions and cut down on the brown sugar, as I they were sweet enough to caramalize on their own. Very traditional, but it had the eastern spices that are different to my palate, as my family is from Russia. To those wondering what to do with the grains, Cholent is usually served on a large platter. Put the in with the cholent and let it all cook together. You end up with beef flavored rice, grain and beans, grain flavored beef and a flavor of browned onions over everything.

    • ronz

    • Washington, DC

    • 8/21/2005

  • Just found this recipe and it seemed iteresting but appears incomplete. What to do with grains and eggs?

    • petichu1

    • 8/15/2005

  • The recipe is incomplete. When ready to serve, what do you do with the two bags of grains?

    • Anonymous

    • 3/14/2005

Read More
Simple Roast Chicken
Chef Thomas Keller’s food is known for fine dining finesse, but his recipe for simple roast chicken is about as easy as it gets.
Chicken Soup
This simple chicken noodle soup recipe from New York’s storied 2nd Avenue Deli makes an extra rich version of Jewish penicillin full of perfectly tender meat.
Rich Turkey Gravy
This easy turkey gravy recipe uses the drippings from the bird (deglazed right in the roasting pan) to give you maximum flavor with just three ingredients.
Tacos de Pobre
These budget-friendly tacos de pobre are packed with crispy, shallow-fried potato skins, plus sautéed onions and chile peppers.
Chile con Queso
Real cheddar cheese meets charred green chiles in our best recipe for queso. For extra points serve the molten dip with warmed tortilla chips.
Succotash
This succotash recipe has some bacon for heft and jalapeños for kick, plus fresh summer corn, lima beans, and okra.
Caprese Salad
Caprese salad thrives on simplicity and using the freshest ingredients possible: heirloom tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil–that’s it!
Smoked Duck
This smoked duck is a beauty, with a burnished finish from the molasses.